January 7, 2009Happy New Year! :)
Home
Home
Email
News
Buzz
Videos
Entertainment
  • Movies
  • Movie Reviews
  • Celebs & Gossip
  • Music
Sports
Technology
Travel
  • India Tourism
  • Flights
  • Hotels
  • Tours & Destinations
  • Car Rentals
  • Airports in India
  • India Flight Arrivals
  • India Flight Departures
  • India Flight Status
Jobs
Hot Topics
  • Mumbai Attacks
  • India Vs England
  • Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi





  • Home
  • News
  • Buzz
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Life Style
  • Technology
  • India.com Email

Free Subscription


Subscribe to India's Most Popular Mailing List!

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Aamir Khan stole idea of 'Taare Zameen Par'

  • Movies
  • Featured Item
  • Yes
November 20, 2008, 9:56 am

Shakuntala Devi infuriated

Wow this is certainly something unexpected from Aamir Khan - apparently the 'perfectionist' of Bollywood very perfectly plagiarized the story of 'Taare Zameen Par' from maths genius Shakuntala Devi.

Shakuntala Devi has accused Aamir Khan Productions of stealing ideas from her own book 'In the wonderland of numbers' and dishing out Taare Zameer Par without giving her any credit. What keeps me wondering is if she was locked up in cryogenic sleep all these months? Or was she paid by Aamir Khan himself for a little publicity before 'Ghajini' releases. Because its been almost a year since TZP released and NOW she breaks it to the media.

Anyways the 69 year old wizardess is now producing her own movie based on her book. "Some of the things shown in Taare Zameen Par have been taken straight from my book. People ask me why I don't sue the producer of the Aamir Khan movie," she said. "I expect him to write a letter explaining why he did this," she said.

Shakuntala Devi spilled these beans during an interview in Beijing. Apparently this is the second time a film producer has stolen her ideas. A Rajesh Khanna starrer, Red Rose used ideas from her short story, The whole world is mad , which was published in Femina magazine, she said. While Red Rose was a big pile of unmentionable, it still matters that the producers gave her squat credit.

She said she had talked to several producers including Kamal Haasan to turn her book, In the wonderland of numbers into a movie. In case you're wondering, the story is about a nine-year-old girl who goes through a transformation from being a mathematics hater to a mathematical genius.

"One producer asked if he can show the heroine as an 18-19 year old girl and introduce a disco number. I said it will destroy the whole purpose of the movie. My mission is to make people fall in love with mathematics and feel the joy of it" she said.

"I am considering Rajnikant or some other producer for the movie. I wrote the book as a movie script", she said.

She said Kamala Haasan told her the proposed movie could cause a worldwide sensation if she found an intelligent producer capable of utilising the material in the book. "But he cannot make this movie. He is usually the hero of his movies. Also, he does not love numbers that much," she said.

"From childhood, I have been asked to compete against computers and I somehow regarded it as my enemy," she said laughing. But her dream project in Bangalore will involve experts from the IT industry as well as rope in Sanskrit scholars who can make sense of intricate Vedic mathematics.

"You know a lot of mathematical knowledge is stored in shlokas and sutras and it is not easy to make the most out of them. We need specialists to research and develop this area," she said.

She has penned as many as 22 books as of now. The maths geek has been shocking audiences across the world since childhood with her prodigious talent of twirling numbers. She is in the process of setting up a global institution on mathematics that will train young minds and do research in Vedic Mathematics. Shakuntala Devi is worried that the advent of computers is harming the thinking ability of children, who are increasing losing interest in mathematics. "Mathematics has already lost its popularity in the West. Now, I feel this is happening in India as well," she said.



  • Thumbnail

Shame on Amir Khan

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 11/29/2008 - 14:50.

Amir Khan claims to be No. 1 bollywood star, but it is bad that he didn't gave any credit to the ORIGINAL creative mind behind taray Zameen per!

  • reply

Interview of Shakuntala Devi in Vedic maths Forum

Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 11/24/2008 - 22:55.

Well, truly the claims are not 100% authentic. It could be that people might have similar ideas at the same time.

And the true success of TZP is execution and not really story. The interview in June 2007 clearly shows, that when Shakuntala devi was looking for a producer to produce this film, Aamir was infact busy completing the shoot for the film.

And Aamir had the story long way before even 2007.

http://vedicmathsindia.blogspot.com/2007/06/in-wonderland-of-numbers.html

  • reply

hello its all NONSENSE

Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 11/24/2008 - 18:35.

above all the story writer of the Movie is AMOLE GUPTE and he had written the script since 8 yrs frm now... Ms Skantula Devi just stop it cos this will not help u in getting fame...

  • reply

TZP

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 11/22/2008 - 15:33.

After a sound sleep for about one whole year Shakuntala Devi has woken up to find that ideas from her book has been stolen by Aamir Khan for the movie "Taare Zameen Par".
--- Jawahar.P.Sekhar

  • reply

Aamir Khan Stole idea of "Taare Zameen Par "

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 11/22/2008 - 12:24.

Hi! Everybody,
It's really very sad to hear that Aamir Stole the story written by Shakuntala Mam but I want to say one thing that Aamir is not that type of person . He is very decent & gentleman. Shakuntala Mam you are also very good. But I think the world is so big and so many children are facing this type of problems what we have seen in "Taare Zameen Par " it's not the matter of stole the story it is a big co-incident that the writer of "Taare Zameen Par " thought the same story . No doubt that the story ,Direction, songs , Acting by all the Actors are Very good in " Taare Zameen Par ". Best wishes To Aamir & Shakuntala Mam .

Mrs. k. Sen

  • reply

TZP

Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 11/25/2008 - 17:00.

Madam,
After reading your comments about TZP , I could not resist remembering an old news item I read in "Indian Express" ( 1980/81). This was a judgement against Shakuntaladevi (in favour of an aged couple who had rented their Flat in Mumbai to her for a long time and who had to approach court for getting it back. Ultimately they won their case to get back their Flat from Shakuntala devi after about ten years of leagal battle.Thejudge had observed that " A woman of Shakuntaladevi's reputation should not have harrassed these old couple for such a long time ( in fact they wanted their Flat back because they didi not have any other place in Mumbai to live in)with the leagal battle.
I don't want to make any comment. You make your own conclution about 'GOOD' Shakuntala mam.
--- Jawahar.P.Sekhar

  • reply

TZP

Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 11/22/2008 - 10:42.

After one year of silence Shakuntala Devi noticed the so called theft of the idea from her book ??? It is ridiculous.

  • reply

NONSENSE

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 11/21/2008 - 14:58.

its all NONSENSE.the story was written by Amol not Aamir.Gawd stop stooping so low for the sake of publicity.

  • reply

Aamir Khan stole idea of 'Taare Zameen Par'

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 11/21/2008 - 01:04.

Hi,

Why this is everytime that after success of great producer or director people wakeup so late or get the fire of jealoussness after the meal is taken away i dont and cant believe this thing because if it's do then why necessary step were not being taken at right time?

I'm sorry to say all this but who will believe this kinda spice and most of the people and nation want some spice to disrespect or disregard someone who is highly honored, why this always happens, when it will come to end? and onething more if you are the right path or on the path for your right then no one can ever cheat or take your talent away from youi believe you'll be more famous and popular and live in the heart of nation and people around the world if you believe in yourself not believing in letting some one down!

Thank& Regards
Your friendly Neighbourhood

  • reply

Aamir Khan stole idea of 'Taare Zameen Par'

Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 11/21/2008 - 13:12.

yeh ur right, this kind of public stunts have now become quite regular in this industry. and the women who is alleging Aamir of stoling, where where she from more than one year or so, and now when she is going to make a film on her own story, trying to make a news and name out of it. and if Aamir has taken the idea then what is wrong in it. one idea can come in many mind.

  • reply

Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Please be polite. Help us keep the Discussions clean and respectful. We take online abuse very seriously. Your comment could take up to 1-2 Hours to show up on the page.

Similar entries

  • First Look: Dicaprio and Kate Winslet's New film
  • Leo Dicaprio and Kate Winslet's new film 02
  • Leo Dicaprio and Kate Winslet's new film 03
  • Leo Dicaprio and Kate Winslet's new film 05
  • Leo Dicaprio and Russel Crowe’s new Movie

What are you Searching for?


India.com Exclusive




Join Us at


More Stories from Movies

  • 10 Biggest Bollywood movies of 2009
  • India.com Hollywood movie Awards Part 2
  • India.com Hollywood movie Awards
  • Kajol to make cameo opposite Aamir in '3 idiots'
  • Deepika without makeup on her 23rd Bday
  • India.com Movie Awards - PART 3
  • Abhishek Bachchan looks drunk in 'Raavan' look
  • Ghajini is 8th biggest Bollywood hit of all time
  • India.com Movie Awards - PART 2
  • 5 Favourite models of 2008
more

More Celebs & Gossip News

  • Big Bollywood Stars' Moolah
  • Sardar Saif Ali
  • Now, Britney Spears' Sex Tape
  • Remembering the Olympic Hotties
  • Rakhi Sawant proposes to Salman Khan
  • The Three Hotties of Fashion
  • SRK, Aamir, Hrithik get together for MTV
  • Aishwarya Rai makes Katrina Kaif Jealous
  • SRK's double Role in Rab Ne bana di jodi
  • The Brand New Babes of Movies and TV
more

Featured

Nokias 5800 XpressMusic Launched in India!

  • Gadgets
  • Featured Item
  • Yes

Start drooling, dudes and dudettes - the stunning new Nokia touchscreen 5800 XpressMusic phone has arrived in India!

...
  • Add new comment
  • Read more

Satyam Chairman involved in Rs 7,000 Crore Fraud

  • India
  • Featured Item
  • Yes

Satyam Computer on Wednesday plunged into a deep crisis, as B Ramalinga Raju resigned as its Chairman after admitting to major financial wrong-doin ...

  • Add new comment
  • Read more

India.com Hollywood movie Awards Part 2

  • Movies
  • Featured Item
  • Yes

Runners Up: (in that order)

  • François BĂ©gaudeau for The Class
  • Jonathan and Christopher Nolan for THE DARK KNIGHT
  • Add new comment
  • Read more

Ganguly will pick Hot IPL Cheerleaders

  • Cricket
  • Featured Item
  • Yes

The Prince of Kolkatta, former Indian cricket captain Sourav Ganguly, will pick a new cheerleader for his Indian Premier League team, the Kolkata K ...

  • Add new comment
  • Read more
more

Recent comments

  • i completely agree with
    1 hour 30 min ago
  • rofl... these celebs deserve
    1 hour 42 min ago
  • is abhishake your relative?
    1 hour 43 min ago
  • you have openly proved
    1 hour 44 min ago
  • piece of trash u say...try
    1 hour 46 min ago
  • A small suggestion to u too,
    1 hour 50 min ago
  • this only shows frustation of writer
    3 hours 1 min ago
  • Please be polite. Help us
    4 hours 20 min ago
  • You have Openly Defaced an
    4 hours 22 min ago
  • i want this
    5 hours 3 min ago

Just in...

  • Motorola launches the MOTOSURF A3100
  • 10 Biggest Bollywood movies of 2009
  • Fuel set to be cheaper soon!
  • In Pics: The 17-inch MacBook Pro
  • Market crashes and burns thanks to Satyam fraud
  • India’s evidence on Mumbai attacks credible: US
  • Pak finally admits Kasab is Pakistani
  • Pietersen resigns as England Captain
  • Here is Satyam Chairman's Apology Letter
  • Kajol to make cameo opposite Aamir in '3 idiots'
  • Abhishek Bachchan looks drunk in 'Raavan' look
  • Tendulkar smashes Century despite having Fever
  • India hands over solid Mumbai evidence to Pak
  • Top 5 Space Launches of 2008
  • Canon's SIX new Video Cameras
Home | Buzz | Entertainment | India Travel | Sports | Life Style | News | Technology | About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Contact Us
This site and domain are not affiliated with or owned by any government or municipal authority.
© 2008 World Media Group LLC.